Clinical neuropsychiatry reveals why patients continue restrictive eating even after achieving weight restoration
When we think of anorexia nervosa treatment, we often imagine a straightforward path: help the person regain weight, and the dangerous behaviors will stop. But clinical neuropsychiatry is revealing a far more complex picture—one where patients continue to severely restrict their calorie intake even after achieving weight restoration 3 8 .
This puzzling phenomenon represents one of the most significant challenges in eating disorder treatment today. Despite reaching what appears to be a healthy weight on the scale, many individuals remain trapped in patterns of restrictive eating and distorted body image 8 . The scale might say "recovered," but the brain tells a different story.
Recent research is now uncovering why this happens—and what it reveals about anorexia as a brain-based disorder rather than simply a weight disorder. The implications are transforming how we understand and treat this life-threatening condition.
Anorexia involves fundamental changes in brain structure and function
Weight restoration doesn't always stop restrictive behaviors
New approaches target both biological and psychological components
Anorexia nervosa is a complex mental health disorder characterized by severe calorie restriction, an intense fear of gaining weight, and a distorted body image 8 . While the physical manifestations of starvation are often visible, the neurological underpinnings are less apparent but equally important.
Involving severe calorie limitation alone 8
Including periods of binge eating followed by purging 8
A landmark 2024 study published in the European Eating Disorders Review put this paradox under the microscope 3 . Researchers investigated whether higher weight gain necessarily translated to reduced eating disorder symptoms in patients with atypical anorexia nervosa (AAN)—a condition where patients exhibit anorexia symptoms without being underweight 3 8 .
The study followed 96 adults receiving specialized eating disorder treatment between December 2020 and May 2023 3 . Researchers measured both weight changes and psychological symptoms using standardized assessment tools, comparing outcomes between those with atypical anorexia and traditional anorexia nervosa 3 .
The findings challenged conventional wisdom about recovery metrics 3 . While all patients showed improvement in their eating disorder symptoms from admission to discharge, the relationship between weight gain and psychological recovery differed dramatically between groups.
| Study Results Comparing Atypical Anorexia (AAN) and Anorexia Nervosa (AN) | ||
|---|---|---|
| Metric | Atypical Anorexia (AAN) | Anorexia Nervosa (AN) |
| EDE-Q Scores | Improved from admission to discharge | Improved from admission to discharge |
| Weight Gain Impact | No association between weight gain and EDE-Q scores | Weight gain associated with lower Restraint scores |
| %EBW at Discharge | Not associated with EDE-Q scores | Associated with EDE-Q Restraint scores |
Interactive visualization would display here
Showing the weak correlation between weight restoration and psychological improvement in AAN
Neuroscience research has identified tangible differences in the brains of people with anorexia that may explain why restrictive eating patterns persist after weight restoration 8 . These include:
Differences in serotonin and dopamine levels that affect appetite, mood, and the brain's reward system 8
Altered activity in regions responsible for body perception and fear response 8
Repeated restrictive behaviors strengthen specific neural circuits, making them automatic and difficult to change
Emerging research suggests that anorexia involves differences in cognitive flexibility—the brain's ability to switch between thinking about different concepts or to adapt behavior to changing situations 8 . This may manifest as:
Getting stuck on specific thoughts about calories, weight, or body image
Continuing restrictive patterns even when the original motivation (low weight) has been addressed
Perceiving weight gain as dangerous even when medically necessary
Traditional anorexia treatment emphasized cautious, slow weight gain due to fears about refeeding syndrome—a potentially fatal metabolic condition that can occur when severely malnourished patients increase calories too quickly 4 6 . However, recent evidence has challenged this approach.
| Comparison of Refeeding Approaches | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Approach | Initial Calorie Level | Weekly Weight Gain | Advantages | Disadvantages |
| Low-Calorie Refeeding (LCR) | <1,400 kcal/day | Slower | Lower perceived risk of refeeding syndrome | Protracted hospital stays; may prolong malnutrition |
| High-Calorie Refeeding (HCR) | 2,000-2,400 kcal/day | 1-2 kg | Faster weight restoration; shorter hospital stays | Requires close medical monitoring |
Specialized centers worldwide—including programs in Australia, Germany, and the United States—have successfully implemented high-calorie refeeding protocols with appropriate medical monitoring and electrolyte supplementation 4 6 . The Johns Hopkins Eating Disorders Program, for instance, has demonstrated that most patients not only tolerate rapid refeeding but also view their treatment experience positively 6 .
Modern anorexia treatment recognizes that addressing both biological and psychological components is essential for meaningful recovery 8 . Effective treatment typically involves:
Establishing regular eating patterns with adequate calories
Addressing distorted thoughts and beliefs about food and body image
Sometimes used to address co-occurring conditions
Especially crucial for adolescent patients
| Psychotherapy Approaches for Anorexia | ||
|---|---|---|
| Therapy Type | Primary Focus | Key Techniques |
| Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) | Identifying and changing distorted thoughts | Cognitive restructuring; behavioral experiments |
| Family-Based Treatment (FBT) | Empowering families to support recovery | Parent-led refeeding; externalizing the illness |
| Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) | Developing psychological flexibility | Mindfulness; values-based action |
The discovery that patients may continue restrictive eating after weight gain has profound implications for how we define and treat recovery in anorexia nervosa. It suggests that:
The good news is that recovery is possible with comprehensive treatment that addresses both the physical and psychological aspects of the disorder 8 . As research continues to unravel the complex neuropsychiatry of anorexia, we move closer to treatments that can help individuals achieve full freedom from this devastating illness.
If you or someone you know is struggling with an eating disorder, help is available. Consider reaching out to:
Available Monday-Friday, 9:00AM-7:00PM EST 1
Free support available between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. EST 1